Because I could not stop for Death, he kindly stopped for me; the carriage held but just ourselves and immortality” – Emily Dickinson If Death took a holiday, the guns would go silent in Iraq, the slaughter on our nation’s highways would cease, and the news media would be compelled to cover positive events in the humanities, arts, and sciences. Unfortunately, Death has not had a vacation in recorded history, but Mitchell Leisen’s 1934 fantasy, Death Takes a Holiday, allows us to consider the possibility. Co-written by Maxwell Anderson and Gladys Lehman and based on the play "La Morte in Vacanza" by Alberto Casella, Death Takes a Holiday stars Frederic March as the Grim Reaper who takes on human form in an attempt to discover why men fear him so much. Why he has waited 5,000 years to satisfy this curiosity is not explained. [Spoiler] After a brief tryout as a shadowy figure who scares the daylights out of those that cross his path, Death shows up at, of all places, an upscale party at an Italian villa, posing as the mysterious Prince Sirki. Only one person knows who he really is, the host Duke Lambert (Guy Standing), and he is sworn to secrecy. Sirki proceeds to fascinate the guests. Given to bursts of wit and poetry, he can just as quickly turn sullen and threatening, and some soon find out that it is better not to look too deeply into his eyes. During the three days in which the Prince is at the villa, however, people all over the world miraculously escape death and potential suicides are doomed to frustration. To see what’s behind all the conversation about love, the suave but naïve Prince Sirki falls for the irresistible Grazia (Evelyn Venable), the daughter of one of Duke’s friends. Grazia knows who Death is but does not fear him, much to the chagrin of her fiancé, Corrado (Kent Taylor) who has developed a strong disdain for Prince Charming. More sinister than Brad Pitt in the 1998 remake Meet Joe Black, March turns in a very convincing performance as the creepy yet strangely appealing guest. Although the ending is melodramatic, the emotions are very real and the suggestion that Death may in reality be a friend disguised as a foe is quite touching. (Howard Schumann, talkingpix.co.uk) In this wearisome and predictable plot line, Death falls in love and bores us to death talking about it. (Dennis Schwartz, homepages.sover.net) I've heard DRACULA was advertised with the tag line "The Weirdest Love Story ever told!" (this is probably a paraphrase), but at heart, I've never felt that you could honestly call that movie a love story. The tag line would be much more appropriate for this one, since it ultimately boils down to what amounts to a love story. This movie is very good indeed, particularly if you consider that it is built around a concept that could have easily been handled in a cute or facile manner. Instead, it is handled as seriously as possible, with some real thought put into how death would try to come to terms with a life and an outlook that was to that point totally unfamiliar to him; much of the credit does go to Fredric March in the title role. It's quite scary when it needs to be, particularly during the first twenty minutes. From then on, it deals with its themes with subtlety, a quiet wit, an enduring sadness, and an everpresent tension on how Death might react if crossed. It's not perfect; some of the dialogue is self-conscious and artificial, as if the writers knew they were dealing with weighty issues and were trying to be profound. But I am certainly glad they didn't try to turn it into a musical comedy of sorts. (Dave Sindelar, scifilm.org) See also the remake: Death Takes A Holiday (1971)
有句台词“I thought you modern girls had no nevers”,女主角比起其他的年轻女性角色,仿佛是走古典优雅风,感觉好像不没女配角们爵士时尚啊,包括嗓音都特别有识别度,跟那种典型的中气十足的嗓音不一样。这让我觉得导演在选角上仿佛是有意而为之,成为对比。本是冲着March看的,但是死神的审美,不大符合我的审美,毕竟里面“morden girls”才是我想看黄金时代电影的原因之一,导致对March这个角色的观感也一般。本以为会是霸道总裁式的故事,没想到掺杂“女主角向往死亡”“现代空虚”等这些点,但电影对此刻画也有限,不是走这条道道,主要还是神秘主义,导致对电影观感也一般般了。
死神全年无休,讨厌上班,给自己放了个三天小长假,化作人形,去凡间走一趟,寻找美好事物,探究何为恐惧,被爱折磨,最终明白生命意义。喜欢这一设定,不禁联想起《模拟人生》作弊玩法,玩家苦苦钻研,如何与死神相爱,痴迷于终极浪漫。
台词好棒啊,就是结尾死神突然感慨“爱情最伟大”balabala有些破坏气氛……早知道死神长这样我就不怕鬼了(?)
March的气质和演技没得说,威严中带着初入人世的好奇,还有死神接着人类“前言”说着南辕北辙的“后语”带出的那种小喜感,最喜欢“我也碰过不少人的肩膀,不过可不是为了换舞伴。”~女主很明显打一开始就对死亡充满了憧憬,但最后影片非要把落脚点放到爱情上,就挺给前面那些关于生命、死亡的讨论拉胯的。
I bound myself to life. And now I must bow to it. 台词真美 死神与少女题材,这部居然是罕见的HE
耻度太高,角色间的互动甚至比不上皮特版。最大优点是时间不长
只要你够帅,死神都有人爱,马奇的喜剧天赋演起来有点萌
死亡也许比生命更加简单、更加友善,但说到底也只是“也许”而已,不确定的事情永远令人恐惧。不赞同爱便是生命的意义、爱让人无惧死亡这类浪漫化的说法,但这片确实许多地方都浪漫十足,像是死神与女主初见时的几步一回眸,死神撩拨衣服上的花朵,还有女主那惝恍飘忽的神情。最后一幕有些不满意。
3.5 有一天,死神在意大利扮作一个王子度假…… 这片竟然有好多好听的配乐!在那个年代真是不容易。
3.5星,虽然舞台剧味道浓重但是演员们的表演都非常走心,马奇的口音真是魔幻。女主角云里雾里不知所谓的样子确实像是某种精神疾患者,用这样的方式去诠释她对人生的选择,不知道究竟是死神太有魅力还是死亡太有吸引力。PS相比新版还是更喜欢这个老版的结尾,颇有点爱伦坡浪漫入骨髓的风范。
看过的最美的关于抑郁症患者的电影。
love is greater than illusion…and strong as death.
马奇的死神略萌,有点他以前演化身博士的感觉。女主眼神飘得很,适合角色。
大学挚友跟我说过曾经很想排练这个剧本,是Meet Joe Black的原型,一直记得。终于有幸看到,真是每一句台词都好美,连看的是英文字幕都察觉不到!有时候根本想象不到原来慢慢地一本正经念台词的戏会如此美妙。
这个片子……好像歌剧,特别是女主角的声音。
莱森的镜头啊!!!!为什么最后死神披上黑袍独白那一幕 半个脑袋都在镜头外面,,,不能忍啊!!!
类似题材都难免流于烂俗 这部算是中规中矩的叙事派 不知是弗雷德里克的表演 还是他外表特有的黑色气质 让这个死神不那么肤浅刻意 像当初看他的化身博士一样 暗黑系绝对是我男神强项
death度假随心所欲, love来的莫名其妙.那时的单片眼镜是怎么戴上去的?很多有趣的台词: state man Fate奇怪没有早点introduce us. Oldman . 拍肩膀for other reason.
目测是根据舞台剧改编的,死神生前是莎剧演员吗?死神享受3天"凡人假期",却爱上一位"小公主",而小公主又对死亡文化很感冒,这个题材用79分钟的长度展现似乎远远不夠,情感剧需要的是细节,很多失败爱情剧就是细节处理失当,导致火花来的不自然。
Fredric March角色对于恐惧与生命的思考很吸引我 阴影真的是阴影吗? 为何人们恐惧死亡与黑暗? 有些台词像古典诗句一般 提出的询问指向外部 最后回到自身 他有一种冷而优雅的气质 孤独 他来到这个世界 冲击了人们 重塑了死亡的概念 爱将会跨过界线